Josué Fiallofiallo.net
ESEN
Career

The constitutional reform of 2009-2010

Between March 2009 and January 2010 the Revising National Assembly debated, voted and proclaimed a new Constitution for the Dominican Republic. Josué Fiallo accompanied that process as an adviser, from three different tables.

  • 59meetings of the Assembly
  • 7,543pages of records
  • 1,254votes documented
  • 277articles in the proclaimed text

Law 70-09, of February 27, 2009, declared the need to reform the Constitution and summoned senators and deputies to sit as the Revising National Assembly. Ten months of work followed: fifty-nine meetings, alternating between the Senate and the Chamber of Deputies, two full readings of the text, article by article, and a proclamation, on January 26, 2010, with the national anthem and a twenty-one gun salute.

Josué Fiallo, a lawyer, served in that process as adviser to the Justice Committee, to the Verification and Audit Committee and to the Presidency of the National Assembly. Three roles and a single craft: making sure that every word approved on the floor was the same word written into the Constitution.

Three roles

Adviser

Justice Committee

The Special Committee on Title V, “The Judiciary”, studied items 44 to 49 of the convening law, articles 126 to 162 of the proposal and its transitional provisions. It was coordinated by Senator Francisco Domínguez Brito, with Deputy Víctor Suárez Díaz as acting coordinator.

It heard the Supreme Court of Justice, the Office of the Attorney General, the Public Defender’s Office and civil society organizations, and weighed twenty-six amendments tabled by members of the Assembly. Its favorable report with modifications, dated July 29, 2009, proposed the Council of the Judiciary, the Superior Council of the Public Prosecution Service and a career service for prosecutors.

Adviser

Verification and Audit Committee

A standing committee created by the Rules of the Assembly and chaired by Assembly member Francisco Rosario Martínez. Its mandate: to check the text approved on first reading against the records, the orders of the day, the votes and the recordings of each meeting, and to point out errors, gaps and contradictions.

Its report, 191 pages long with a proposed text of 88, included thirty reconsiderations and opened the second reading on September 17, 2009. Together with the Style Committee it later reviewed the text approved on second reading, in the report the plenary took up on November 16, 2009.

Adviser

Presidency of the National Assembly

The Revising National Assembly was presided over by Reinaldo Pared Pérez, President of the Senate, with Julio César Valentín Jiminián, President of the Chamber of Deputies, as Vice President.

The Presidency conducted the fifty-nine meetings, set the procedure for each reading with the Coordinating Committee and carried the text through to its proclamation.

The archive

Timeline

  1. Law 70-09 declares the need for the reform and convenes the Revising National Assembly.
  2. First meeting of the Assembly. The first reading begins.
  3. The Special Committee on Title V delivers its report on the Judiciary.
  4. Meeting number 40, the last of the first reading.
  5. The Verification and Audit Committee presents its report. The second reading begins.
  6. Meeting number 57, the last of the second reading.
  7. The plenary takes up the report reviewing the text approved on second reading.
  8. Proclamation of the reformed Constitution.

The fifty-nine meetings

Each meeting left a verbatim record. The list below comes from those records: date, number, type of meeting, venue where stated, and length of the record. Each meeting opens its own page, with the full record and its votes.

First reading

  • March 24, 2009

    Meeting 001

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 159-page record · 27 votes · First reading begins

  • April 14, 2009

    Meeting 002

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 237-page record · 17 votes

  • April 15, 2009

    Meeting 003

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 159-page record · 12 votes

  • April 16, 2009

    Meeting 004

    Ordinary meeting · 191-page record · 22 votes

  • April 21, 2009

    Meeting 005

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 167-page record · 35 votes

  • April 22, 2009

    Meeting 006

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 107-page record · 18 votes

  • April 28, 2009

    Meeting 007

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 183-page record · 26 votes

  • April 29, 2009

    Meeting 008

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 168-page record · 23 votes

  • April 30, 2009

    Meeting 009

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 162-page record · 33 votes

  • May 5, 2009

    Meeting 010

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 148-page record · 27 votes

  • May 6, 2009

    Meeting 011

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 185-page record · 29 votes

  • May 7, 2009

    Meeting 012

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 92-page record · 19 votes

  • May 12, 2009

    Meeting 013

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 10-page record

  • May 13, 2009

    Meeting 014

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 208-page record · 50 votes

  • May 14, 2009

    Meeting 015

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 15-page record

  • May 19, 2009

    Meeting 016

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 175-page record · 20 votes

  • May 20, 2009

    Meeting 017

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 22-page record

  • May 26, 2009

    Meeting 018

    Ordinary meeting · 160-page record · 23 votes

  • May 27, 2009

    Meeting 019

    Ordinary meeting · 142-page record · 19 votes

  • June 2, 2009

    Meeting 020

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 101-page record · 27 votes

  • June 4, 2009

    Meeting 021

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 10-page record

  • June 9, 2009

    Meeting 022

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 130-page record · 23 votes

  • June 10, 2009

    Meeting 023

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 161-page record · 27 votes

  • June 16, 2009

    Meeting 024

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 140-page record · 24 votes

  • June 17, 2009

    Meeting 025

    Ordinary meeting · 132-page record · 35 votes

  • June 18, 2009

    Meeting 026

    Ordinary meeting · 126-page record · 28 votes

  • June 23, 2009

    Meeting 027

    Ordinary meeting · 56-page record · 6 votes

  • June 24, 2009

    Meeting 028

    Ordinary meeting · 53-page record · 5 votes

  • June 30, 2009

    Meeting 029

    Ordinary meeting · 47-page record

  • July 1, 2009

    Meeting 030

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 141-page record · 14 votes

  • July 7, 2009

    Meeting 031

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 16-page record

  • July 9, 2009

    Meeting 032

    Ordinary meeting · 153-page record · 35 votes

  • July 14, 2009

    Meeting 033

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 51-page record · 10 votes

  • July 15, 2009

    Meeting 034

    Ordinary meeting · 185-page record · 32 votes

  • July 21, 2009

    Meeting 035

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 132-page record · 27 votes

  • July 23, 2009

    Meeting 036

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 149-page record · 33 votes

  • July 29, 2009

    Meeting 037

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 80-page record · 7 votes

  • July 30, 2009

    Meeting 038

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 71-page record · 11 votes

  • August 5, 2009

    Meeting 039

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 185-page record · 52 votes

  • August 25, 2009

    Meeting 040

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 59-page record · 17 votes · First reading ends

Second reading

  • September 17, 2009

    Meeting 041

    Ordinary meeting · 194-page record · 30 votes · Verification and Audit report

  • September 21, 2009

    Meeting 042

    Extraordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 10-page record

  • September 22, 2009

    Meeting 043

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 168-page record · 43 votes

  • September 28, 2009

    Meeting 044

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 159-page record · 14 votes

  • September 29, 2009

    Meeting 045

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 119-page record · 18 votes

  • September 30, 2009

    Meeting 046

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 122-page record · 27 votes

  • October 1, 2009

    Meeting 047

    Ordinary meeting · 132-page record · 21 votes

  • October 5, 2009

    Meeting 048

    Ordinary meeting · 220-page record · 49 votes

  • October 6, 2009

    Meeting 049

    Ordinary meeting · 185-page record · 42 votes

  • October 8, 2009

    Meeting 050

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 113-page record · 21 votes

  • October 12, 2009

    Meeting 051

    Extraordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 111-page record · 11 votes

  • October 13, 2009

    Meeting 052

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 11-page record

  • October 14, 2009

    Meeting 053

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 29-page record · 1 vote

  • October 19, 2009

    Meeting 054

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 199-page record · 37 votes

  • October 20, 2009

    Meeting 055

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 178-page record · 41 votes

  • October 21, 2009

    Meeting 056

    Ordinary meeting · Chamber of Deputies · 184-page record · 33 votes

  • October 22, 2009

    Meeting 057

    Ordinary meeting · Senate of the Republic · 185-page record · 44 votes · Second reading ends

Final review and proclamation

  • November 16, 2009

    Meeting 058

    Extraordinary meeting · 95-page record · 6 votes · Review report

  • January 26, 2010

    Meeting 059

    Extraordinary meeting · 261-page record · 3 votes · Proclamation

Sources: records of the National Assembly convened under Law 70-09; report of the Special Committee on Title V, July 29, 2009; report of the Standing Committee on Verification and Audit, September 2009. Photograph: meeting of the Revising National Assembly, October 22, 2009.